Solved thermodynamics exercise

Work in a polytropic transformation PVk=constPV^k=\text{const}

Exercise 14 · Lesson 5Application to the Ideal Gas

  • polytropic transformation
  • pressure work
  • Laplace's law

Statement

Consider a quasi-static transformation of an ideal gas such that PVk=constPV^k=\text{const}, with kRk\in\mathbb{R} and k1k\neq1.

  1. Calculate WABW_{A\to B} in terms of PA,VA,PB,VBP_A,V_A,P_B,V_B, and kk.
  2. Recover the result for an isobaric transformation (k=0k=0).
  3. What is its value for an isochoric transformation (without using the preceding formula)?
  4. What happens when k=1k=1? Recover W=nRTln(VB/VA)W=-nRT\ln(V_B/V_A).

Hint

Hint
Set P(V)=CVkP(V)=CV^{-k} with C=PAVAkC=P_AV_A^k, integrate, then use CV1k=PVCV^{1-k}=PV.

Detailed solution

Solution
Question 1. The polytropic relation can be written

PVk=C,P(V)=CVk,C=PAVAk=PBVBk.PV^k=C, \qquad P(V)=CV^{-k}, \qquad C=P_AV_A^k=P_BV_B^k.

Using the banker's convention, the work received by the gas is

WAB=VAVBP(V)dV=CVAVBVkdV.W_{A\to B} =-\int_{V_A}^{V_B}P(V)\,\mathrm{d}V =-C\int_{V_A}^{V_B}V^{-k}\,\mathrm{d}V.

For k1k\neq1, an antiderivative of VkV^{-k} is V1k/(1k)V^{1-k}/(1-k). Thus,

WAB=C1k(VB1kVA1k)=CVA1kCVB1k1k.W_{A\to B} =-\frac{C}{1-k} \left(V_B^{1-k}-V_A^{1-k}\right) =\frac{CV_A^{1-k}-CV_B^{1-k}}{1-k}.

Now

CVA1k=PAVA,CVB1k=PBVB.CV_A^{1-k}=P_AV_A, \qquad CV_B^{1-k}=P_BV_B.

Finally,

WAB=PAVAPBVB1k=PBVBPAVAk1.\boxed{ W_{A\to B} =\frac{P_AV_A-P_BV_B}{1-k} =\frac{P_BV_B-P_AV_A}{k-1} }.

Question 2. For k=0k=0, the relation PV0=CPV^0=C becomes P=CP=C: the transformation is isobaric. Since PA=PB=PP_A=P_B=P,

WAB=PAVAPBVB=P(VAVB)=P(VBVA)=PΔV.W_{A\to B} =P_AV_A-P_BV_B =P(V_A-V_B) =-P(V_B-V_A) =-P\Delta V.

This recovers the direct expression for isobaric work.

Question 3. For an isochoric transformation, VB=VAV_B=V_A and dV=0\mathrm{d}V=0 at all times. Consequently,

WAB=ABPdV=0.W_{A\to B}=-\int_A^B P\,\mathrm{d}V=0.

A nontrivial isochoric transformation does not correspond to any finite value of kk: if VV is constant, the relation PVk=constPV^k=\text{const} would also require PP to be constant. The isochoric transformation can only be regarded as the formal limit kk\to\infty.

Question 4. For k=1k=1, the integrand is proportional to 1/V1/V: the antiderivative is no longer a power but a logarithm. The integration must therefore be performed separately. The polytropic relation becomes

PV=C.PV=C.

For a closed ideal gas, PV=nRTPV=nRT; the temperature is therefore constant and C=nRTC=nRT. The work received is then

WAB=VAVBnRTVdV=nRTln ⁣(VBVA).W_{A\to B} =-\int_{V_A}^{V_B}\frac{nRT}{V}\,\mathrm{d}V =-nRT\ln\!\left(\frac{V_B}{V_A}\right).

For a compression, VB/VA<1V_B/V_A<1, so the logarithm is negative and WAB>0W_{A\to B}>0, as expected.